Subscribe!
The Art of the Deal: Billions Invested, Illegal Workers, Shadow Payrolls — A Warning for America
When Georgia officials cut a $2 billion deal with Hyundai Motor Group and LG Energy Solution to build a massive electric vehicle battery plant outside Savannah, it was hailed as the largest economic development project in state history. Governor Brian Kemp called it a once-in-a-generation opportunity – a transformational investment. The billions invested by the state and the federal government were under the conditions of bringing 8,100 high-paying jobs to Georgia families – with average $58,000 a year paychecks.
But the story changed on September 4th, when federal agents swarmed the Hyundai site in the largest workplace immigration raid in U.S. history. Nearly 475 workers — most of them South Korean nationals — were detained, exposing a “shadow payroll system†that bypassed U.S. labor laws, unions, and worker protections. While that system was unique and remarkable due to the large number of people involved – it was not unique nationwide, especially when millions in credits and incentives are involved.
—
The $2 Billion Deal
To secure Hyundai’s Metaplant, the state of Georgia stacked up a rich package of incentives:
– State of Georgia: $1.3 billion in job tax credits, sales tax exemptions, infrastructure improvements, and free workforce training.
– Local governments: $700 million in land deals, property tax abatements and bond financing.
– Federal layer: Hyundai and LG also qualify for billions in federal Inflation Reduction Act clean-energy credits.
From the announcement:
“Hyundai Motor Group Metaplant America (HMGMA) is reshaping Georgia’s manufacturing landscape with its first dedicated mass-production EV and hybrid plant. At full production, the cutting-edge Metaplant will be able to support the production of 500,000 units of Hyundai, Kia, and Genesis electric and hybrid vehicles annually.
This historic $7.59 billion investment will create at least 8,500 new jobs on-site at the Metaplant and has spurred nearly 6,900 additional new jobs and $2.5 billion in investments through direct, offsite suppliers in Georgia.
Hyundai Motor Group’s total investments in Georgia are expected to create nearly 40,000 direct and indirect jobs and $4.6 billion in individual earnings every year, according to a report from the Center for Automotive Research”
The pitch was simple: taxpayers would give up revenue up front to secure long-term prosperity. But the raid calls into question whether Georgia’s citizens got anything they were promised.
—
Subcontractors and Shadow Payrolls
The workers detained were not directly employed by Hyundai or LG. Instead, they came through layers of subcontractors and labor brokers, many of them Korean-owned.
Most at least entered the U.S. legally under the Visa Waiver Program or short-term visitor visas. But they were not authorized to work, and many overstayed. Once in Georgia, they were placed on construction crews doing critical weld, pipe, and electrical work — or the in-plant jobs of making EV batteries to go into Hyundai autos – jobs that could have been targeted to local tradespeople.
Their food, housing, and even transportation were often bundled into the job and deducted from their pay, echoing the old company-town model. What looked like $15–$25 an hour – a far cry from $58,000/year – on paper, would shrink further after deductions.
Essentially, it was a shadow payroll system run through subcontractors — outside the reach of federal job benefits, from Social Security and unemployment insurance to worker’s comp, healthcare, sick time, and OSHA oversight. Caring for families in this country was not a concern as most, if not all workers who came into the US for Hyundai jobs were males, and came alone.
—
Life in On-site Housing and Cheap Motels
Far from settling in area neighborhoods, workers lived in trailers, extended-stay motels, or shared apartments, clustered near the job site. Food was handled through communal kitchens with Korean staples bought in bulk, often deducted from paychecks. The in-plant canteen charged “reasonable” prices for food, same as in-plant medical care, seeking to keep people on the job.
For many workers, the arrangement made sense: even reduced wages were higher than they could earn at home, and money sent back to families in South Korea stretched further. Workers were not bringing families with them – most were single men, some skilled and some laborers.
For Georgia, it meant the jobs weren’t creating anything for local families, the tax base, or the community growth politicians had promised at the ribbon cuttings of this massive facility.
In the official announcement made by the state of Georgia:Â Georgia is committed to providing a diverse and skilled workforce for its industries. Georgia Quick Start, the No. 1 workforce training program in the nation, is constructing a customized training center at the Metaplant site. HMGMA has also partnered with local technical colleges to prepare students for entry-level employment at the Metaplant.
—
Union Suspicions
While federal officials have not said what triggered the investigation, labor experts note that local trade unions may have played a role. The Hyundai/LG project was billed as thousands of good-paying jobs, yet many union contractors and skilled local workers were shut out. Seeing hundreds of Korean crews instead of Georgia tradespeople, unions likely raised questions — and may have helped direct investigators’ attention, or a whistleblower or two. As it became clear this practice was going to be the working model, the risk of whistleblowing from a variety of sources only grew. The investigation by authorities was said to have been underway “for months”.
—
Political Fallout
For Governor Kemp, the Hyundai/LG plant was supposed to be a signature achievement. Now, it’s linked to a scandal showing jobs going overseas and into trailers, not into Georgia homes or economy.
For the administration, the raid demonstrates a tough stance on immigration — even at the cost of embarrassing a Republican governor. Gov. Kemp and Pres. Trump have long feuded, and Kemp is term limited now. The raid seems to have been kept at the federal level. It does not appear that Georgia officials had been involved or were aware of the action.
For South Korea, the deal worked: Hyundai and LG gain access to U.S. subsidies, Korean suppliers expand in Georgia, and workers send money back home. But, past the government’s protests that they knew nothing about the plant’s strategically planned non-compliance with US law, it would seem difficult to believe that, based on the sheer size of the plant, the exporting of people, etc. At least publicly they are in a “shock and awe” public response – vowing to send high officials to Georgia to change the way the plant operates. For now, the plant is shuttered.
—
What Happens Next
Production at the plant – as well as construction of the ever-expanding battery facility has been halted pending federal investigation and outcome. The loss of 450 workers or more will put production back months. Hyundai has placed its North America Chief Manufacturing Officer in charge of the site to enforce compliance. The plant includes other sub-companies, most So. Korea affiliated, with the same sub-contracting model and it’s unclear if they are still operating or not.
The raid raised a deeper question: what exactly did Georgia buy with $2 billion in taxpayer incentives?
—
Reality Check: Promises vs. Reality
What Georgia Promised
– 8,100 local jobs averaging $58,000
– Families moving into Bryan County
– Long-term boost for schools and tax base
What the Raid Revealed
– 475 foreign workers now in federal custody
– Housing, food, medical deductions from pay
– A shadow payroll system that bypassed U.S. labor protections
– Remittances flowing back to South Korea
👉 Georgia bet $2B on “good jobs.†Instead, the first big headline after the big ribbon-cutting is a “federal raid”.
___
Hyundai not alone in Georgia
With a commitment to expand EV development in Georgia, the state listed all the companies coming into or expanding in the state, creating an unbroken statewide supplier network:
—
Bottom Line
The Hyundai raid wasn’t just about immigration. It was about the gap between the promise and the practice of America’s mega-deals: politicians tout jobs and prosperity, while the subcontractor labor network cuts costs with shadow labor systems. The bigger the number of workers needed, the funds to be raised, the bigger the risk of wrong-doing.
The “art of the deal†delivered ribbon-cuttings and headlines. What Georgia actually got — at least so far — were workers that were not Georgians – salaries as low as $15/hr (not $58K/yr), - and a federal raid that stopped production cold. The good relations the US had just solidified with South Korea are likely to continue and grow – albeit with this as a major embarrassment to So. Korea, much as they protest they were in the dark. Other models that could be replicated in other SK-US employment deals are also now less likely to occur and scrutiny will be high.
With millions and billions being announced by multiple countries for America, the raid raises tough questions for state leaders, federal policy, and how global companies use incentives – and a warning not to trust foreign governments to set things up right in the US – but to check and verify.
What’s Next for the Detained Workers?
The detained individuals—nearly 475 total—were mostly South Korean nationals and are held at an ICE detention facility in Folkston, Georgia. While deportation would be the next step, after a case by case review, the government of South Korea has just announced that it will send private planes to bring their citizens home: Kang Hoon-sik, chief of staff for President Lee Jae Myung, said that South Korea and the U.S. had finalized negotiations on the workers’ release, and So. Korea will send a charter plane(s) to bring the workers home as soon as remaining administrative steps are completed.
U.S. Government’s Position
- The White House reiterated that foreign workers must enter and work in the U.S. with proper authorization. Violations won’t be tolerated—even on major corporate projects.
- ICE emphasized that the operation was part of months of investigation into illegal employment—not a raid launched without evidence.
- Will there be fines levied against the workers – to be paid by the government? That is unclear.
South Korea agreed in July to purchase $100 billion in U.S. energy and make a $350 billion investment in the U.S. in return for the U.S lowering tariff rates.